← All articles · The Future of Being Human on Substack

AI: The Medium is the "Massage?"

Marshall McLuhan, The Medium is the Message, and other highlights from this week's episode of Modem Futura

By Andrew Maynard · February 18, 2025 · Original post · Download Markdown · Print / save as PDF


[Image: Image: Midjourney (using version 6.1) — view image]

There’s a point in this week’s episode of Modem Futura where I fall into a literary trap head first! Sean was talking about Marshall McLuhan’s 1967 book on media and messaging — a book which I am embarrassed to say I haven’t read — and on handing me a copy, I read the title out as “The Medium is the Message.”

Of course, anyone familiar with the book will know that it’s titled “The Medium is the Massage” — and I’d been “massaged” into misreading it!

Embarrassment aside, I was quite taken aback by the connections between McLuhan’s 1967 observations and what’s currently playing out with AI.

We explore a number of other topics in the podcast before we get to The Medium is the Massage, which is why you might find the time stamped and linked topics below helpful. But this was such a serendipitous and revelatory conversation that you might want to listen to (or watch) the whole episode: available below, and all the other places you find podcasts (including Apple, Spotify and YouTube)

[Podcast: AI: the Medium is the Message on Apple Podcasts]

You can also jump right in to the conversation at these entry points:

00:00 Pre-show banter

00:53 Zoom backgrounds

06:17 Intro to the episode

07:43 Update: Writing a dissertation with OpenAI’s Deep Research

10:48 The power of AI + human

13:10 AI and the Artisanal Intellectual

15:30 Elon Musk and OpenAI

17:20 The AI capabilities vs implementation gap

21:40 The move toward reasoning AI models becoming the primary models

24:40 Marshall McLuhan and The Medium is the Message

25:40 The Medium is the Massage

27:50 Technological affordances and adjacent possibilities

31:50 Technological playgrounds vs playpens

32:50 Permissionless Innovation

36:45 Connecting the global village

42:30 Human ingenuity

46:30 Is technology robbing us of our identity?

48:40 We had to bring in Socrates (and a great quote on the evils of technology)

51:40 When does tech history stop repeating itself?

53:00 Neil Postman on five things to know about technological change

55:15 Revisiting permissionless innovation

57:00 Is there something fundamental to being human that is intransient?

1:00:20 The value of being an amateur rather than a professional

1:03:00 Are professionals constrained to playpens of the imagination?

1:05:20 Oppenheimer and having and open mind

1:06:55 The future of being human and enabling creative thinkers

And finally, a reminder that you can watch is recording this week’s episode on YouTube:

[YouTube video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=P63eIzbLIMM]

As always, if you’re enjoying these conversations on Modem Futura, please don’t forget to subscribe wherever you listen to your podcasts so you get new episodes delivered as they’re released.

And, of course, every rating or review helps us get better at what we’re doing — thanks in advance 😊